----- > [!proposition] Proposition. ([[dual of quotient is annihilator]] - algebraic) > If $W \leq V$ is an inclusion of [[vector space|vector spaces]], then $W^{*}= \frac{V^{*}}{W^{\circ}} \text{ and } \left( \frac{V}{W} \right)^{*} = W^{\circ},$ where $(\cdot)^{*}$ denotes (algebraic) [[dual vector space|dual]] and $(\cdot)^{\circ}$ denotes [[orthogonal complement|annihilator]]. We use equal signs to emphasize the [[natural transformation|naturality]] of these [[linear map|linear]] [[isomorphism|isomorphisms]]. > The second isomorphism holds more generally in [[module|the]] [[category]] $R$-$\mathsf{Mod}$. The first does not! ^proposition > [!proposition] Proposition. ([[dual of quotient is annihilator]] - topological; Theorem 5.18) > The identity $\left( \frac{V}{W} \right)^{*}=W^{\circ}$ > cleanly transfers to [[topological vector space|TVS]] setting with [[continuous]] [[dual vector space|duals]]. Note than in (say) $\mathsf{Norm_{T}}$, one will [[characterization of quotienting a (semi)normed vector space|as usual]] want $W$ [[closed set|closed]] to get an earnest [[norm]] on the [[quotient module|quotient]]. The other identity $W^{*}=\frac{V^{*}}{W^{\circ}}$ > holds for [[norm|normed]] (more generally [[locally convex space|locally convex]]) spaces, but the proof needs [[Hahn-Banach Extension Theorem|Hahn-Banach]] (it uses Theorem 5.16) and indeed can fail in $\mathsf{TVS}$. If $V$ is finite-dimensional, then taking duals on both sides of the first identity and using $W^{* *}=W$ and the second identity, we get a further [[natural transformation|natural isomorphism]] $W=$ then we get additional [[natural transformation|natural isomorphisms]] $W=\frac{V}{}$ $$ > [!proof]+ Proof. ([[dual of quotient is annihilator]]) > **Isomorphism 1.** Let $\iota:W \hookrightarrow V$ denote [[inclusion map|inclusion]]. The [[dual map]] $\iota^{*}$ is restriction to $W$: $\begin{align} > V^{*} &\xrightarrow{\iota^{*} }W^{*} \\ > \varphi & \mapsto \varphi |_{W}. > \end{align}$ > $\iota^{*}$ is a [[surjection]] since $\iota$ is an [[injection]]. We have $\operatorname{ker }\iota^{*}=\{ \varphi \in V^{*}: \varphi |_{W} \equiv 0 \}=W^{\circ}.$ > [[characterization of quotienting a module|By]] [[first isomorphism theorem for modules|the FIT]], we conclude $W^{*} \cong \frac{V^{*}}{W^{\circ}}$. > > > > **Isomorphism 2.** Any element $\overline{\varphi} \in (\frac{V}{W})^{*}$ [[characterization of quotienting a module|induces]] a unique $\varphi \in V^{*}$ such that the [[diagram]] commutes: > > ```tikz > \usepackage{tikz-cd} > \usepackage{amsmath} > \begin{document} > % https://tikzcd.yichuanshen.de/#N4Igdg9gJgpgziAXAbVABwnAlgFyxMJZABgBpiBdUkANwEMAbAVxiRADUQBfU9TXfIRRkAjFVqMWbdgHoA6t14gM2PASIjy4+s1aIQAa27iYUAObwioAGYAnCAFskZEDghIRPG-aeIXbpAAmah0pfQAdcJgADyw4HDgAAgBCRMj6WzQACyxFb0cPagDEYIldNkiIGhhbBiwwGGB0ukycrhBqBjoAIxgGAAV+NSEQWywzLJxjLiA > \begin{tikzcd} > V \arrow[d] \arrow[r, "\exists ! \varphi"] & k \\ > V/W \arrow[ru, "\overline{\varphi}"'] & > \end{tikzcd} > \end{document} > ``` > > This situation is encoded by the [[linear map|linear map]] $\begin{align} > \left( \frac{V}{W} \right)^{*} &\xrightarrow{\Psi} W^{\circ} \\ > \overline{\varphi} & \mapsto \varphi, \text{ where }\varphi(v)= \overline{\varphi}(v + W) > \end{align}$ > where we've noted $\varphi \in W^{\circ}$ when corestricting $V^{*}$ to $W^{\circ}$. By the '$\ex ! \varphi part of the [[universal property]], $\Psi$ is a [[bijection]], hence a [[linear isomorphism]]. > > (We essentially redid this proof all the time when discussing [[relative singular homology|relative cohomology]], e.g. in [[compactly supported cohomology]].) ----- #### The second isomorphism can also be obtained from the first as follows. Start with the [[characterization of quotienting a (semi)normed vector space|quotient operator]] $\pi:X \to X / Y$ and [[quotient operators are dual to embeddings|dualize]] to the embedding $\pi^{*}:\left( \frac{X}{Y} \right)^{*} \hookrightarrow X^{*}$. Then $\operatorname{im }\pi^{*}=(\operatorname{ker }\pi)^{\circ}=Y^{\circ}$. [[kernel and image of the adjoint]] ---- #### References > [!backlink] > ```dataview > TABLE rows.file.link as "Further Reading" > FROM [[]] > FLATTEN file.tags as Tag > WHERE Tag = "#definition" OR Tag = "#theorem" OR Tag = "#MOC" OR Tag = "#proposition" OR Tag = "#axiom" > GROUP BY Tag > ``` > [!frontlink] > ```dataview > TABLE rows.file.link as "Further Reading" > FROM outgoing([[]]) > FLATTEN file.tags as Tag > WHERE Tag = "#definition" OR Tag = "#theorem" OR Tag = "#MOC" OR Tag = "#proposition" OR Tag = "#axiom" > GROUP BY Tag > ```